TL;DR
Get movie nights delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the show’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode. Jimmy Kimmel discussed the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live, citing the pair’s online attention and joking about taking legal action.
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the competition’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode. Jimmy Kimmel discussed the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live, referring to the pair’s online popularity and dance performance. The program’s reported results placed them in the bottom two before they were sent home.
Kimmel showed viewers a chart comparing YouTube views for the pair’s performances. He said Guillermo and Carson had 719,000 views the previous week, while Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, listed second on the chart, had 231,000. That is a comparison of views in the chart Kimmel presented; it does not establish how audience votes were cast or how the show’s voting system weighed online attention.
The eliminated pair performed a Salsa to Bad Bunny during the Super Bowl-themed episode. The judges gave them a combined 22 out of 40: Carrie Ann Inaba and Joe Buck each awarded six points, while Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli each gave five. Kimmel called it Guillermo’s highest score to date and noted that the pair had again landed in the bottom two. The episode’s outcome shows that the judges’ marks and Kimmel’s cited view counts did not prevent their elimination.
After the results, Kimmel spoke with Guillermo and Carson backstage. Asked whether they would accept the result or take legal action, Guillermo replied, “I think we should take legal action,” and Carson agreed. The exchange was presented as a joke, not an announcement of a legal challenge. Kimmel praised Carson’s choreography and joked that she had shaped Guillermo “into a masterpiece.” Carson said she would miss working with him, then joked that Kimmel could have him back.
Dancing with the Stars · Season 35 · Week 5
A Surprising DWTS Departure Leaves Jimmy Kimmel Fuming at Voters
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson exited after a Super Bowl-themed Salsa. Kimmel questioned the result on his late-night show, pointing to online views and the pair’s latest judges’ score.
The exchange that got a laugh
“I think we should take legal action.”Guillermo Rodriguez, joking backstage with Kimmel
01 / The result
Online attention did not save the pair
Kimmel showed a YouTube-view comparison on Jimmy Kimmel Live. It illustrates platform attention, but it cannot explain how viewers voted or how voting was combined with judges’ scores.
Nearly 3.1× the next listed act
Kimmel said Guillermo and Carson had 719,000 views the previous week. Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were listed second with 231,000. These are YouTube views—not vote counts.
02 / The scorecard
A 22-point Salsa, then elimination
The four judges named in the recap awarded two sixes and two fives. Kimmel called it Guillermo’s highest score yet and said the pair landed in the bottom two again.
Kimmel’s reaction
Support, with a joke attached
Kimmel said he thought the routine deserved “an 11 out of 10”—an expression of support, not an official score. He also praised Carson’s choreography and joked that she had shaped Guillermo “into a masterpiece.”
03 / What happened next
From backstage banter to the next week
The reported exchange was comedic. No formal legal challenge or review of the voting process is reported.
The pair was placed in the bottom two and then eliminated.
Kimmel asked whether they would accept it or take legal action.
Guillermo agreed, and Carson went along with the gag.
Dedication Night was scheduled for the following Tuesday.
04 / The evidence boundary
What the reported details can—and can’t—show
Known
Score and outcome
The account gives a 22 out of 40 judges’ total and says Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated.
Known
View comparison
Kimmel cited 719,000 YouTube views for the pair and 231,000 for the next act listed on his chart.
Unreported
Voting breakdown
No vote totals, contestant-by-contestant audience breakdown, or complete scoring standings are supplied.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
Jimmy Kimmel · on Jimmy Kimmel Live
05 / Quick answers
What viewers may want to know
Who was eliminated?
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson, after the Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode.
Were they taking legal action?
No formal action is reported. Guillermo’s remark came during a joking backstage conversation.
When is the next episode?
The recap says the next Tuesday episode was scheduled to feature Dedication Night. The show airs on ABC and Disney+ at 8 p.m. ET/PT, with Hulu streaming the following day.
Why were they eliminated?
The available account does not provide enough voting detail to explain the result. YouTube views are not vote totals.
Online Attention Did Not Save the Pair
Kimmel’s chart showed a difference between the YouTube views he cited for the pair and the views for the next performers listed. Those figures measure views on one platform, not votes, and do not establish why Guillermo and Carson were eliminated.
Kimmel discussed the departure on his late-night program, where Guillermo is a familiar figure. His remarks addressed the result and the pair’s performance; they do not provide evidence that the elimination was improper.
Top picks for "surpris dwts departure"
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Week 5 Scores and Results
The episode was the fifth week of Season 35 and used a Super Bowl theme. Guillermo and Carson danced a Salsa to a Bad Bunny song and received 22 points from the four judges named in the recap. Kimmel contrasted that score with his view that the routine deserved an 11 out of 10, an exaggerated expression of his support rather than an official score.
Guillermo and Carson had already been in the bottom two in an earlier episode, according to Kimmel’s account. He said the pair had relied on viewers to pull them through that time as well. The supplied account does not give the complete standings, the full set of contestants’ scores, or a breakdown of the audience voting, so those details cannot be used to explain the elimination.
Dancing with the Stars airs on ABC and Disney+ on Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT, with episodes streaming the following day on Hulu. The next episode is scheduled around “Dedication Night,” according to the published programming information.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel, on Jimmy Kimmel Live
Voting Details Remain Unreported
The available account does not provide vote totals, a breakdown of viewer votes by contestant, or the method used to combine audience voting with judges’ scores. Kimmel’s YouTube comparison is a measure of online views, not a count of votes, and there is no evidence here that the figures correspond directly to the show’s voting results.
It is also not clear from the reported exchange whether the episode’s scoring or voting process will be reviewed. The legal-action comments were made during a comedic backstage conversation and were not presented as a formal threat or an actual filing. No further explanation for the elimination is given.
The Competition Moves to Dedication Night
Dancing with the Stars is set to continue with Dedication Night in the following week. The remaining contestants will proceed without Guillermo and Carson; the available account does not specify who will be eliminated next or provide further details about the upcoming performances.
For viewers seeking more information about the result, the key missing detail is an official account of the voting figures and how they contributed to the decision. Until those figures are published, Kimmel’s reaction and the YouTube chart offer commentary and context, but not a complete explanation of how the elimination was determined.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Key Questions
Who was eliminated from Dancing with the Stars?
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated after the Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode.
What score did Guillermo and Witney receive?
The four judges gave the pair a combined 22 out of 40: two sixes and two fives.
Why was Jimmy Kimmel upset about the result?
Kimmel had supported the pair and pointed to the YouTube view counts he showed on his program, as well as Guillermo’s latest judges’ score. Those details do not reveal how audience voting worked or why the pair was eliminated.
Are Guillermo and Witney taking legal action?
No formal legal action is reported. Guillermo’s agreement to take legal action came during a joking backstage exchange with Kimmel.
When is the next Dancing with the Stars episode?
The next episode is scheduled for the following Tuesday and is set to feature Dedication Night. The show airs at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with streaming on Hulu the next day.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
